If the blame game were an Olympic sport, this week’s Torah reading, Tol’dot, would take home the gold – with a record-breaking performance in finger-pointing, fault-finding, and family dysfunction.
At the center of the drama is the sibling rivalry between Jacob and Esau, with the seeds of resentment sown before the brothers are even born. The twins struggle in their mother Rebecca’s womb, prompting her to seek divine counsel. Two nations are within her, God explains, and the elder will serve the younger. Esau emerges first with Jacob a close second, his very name derived from his refusal to let go of his brother’s heel. Esau, a ruddy man of the field, is his father’s favorite. Jacob, a mild-mannered tent dweller, is favored by his mother. One day Esau returns from the field famished to find Jacob preparing a bowl of lentil stew. Esau demands something to eat and Jacob sees the opportunity: the bowl for the birthright. The deal is sealed.
The real drama is the second act. Isaac, now old and blind, summons his son Esau and instructs him to prepare a meal before receiving his father’s final, innermost blessing. Rebecca overhears the conversation and devises a scheme. She instructs Jacob to impersonate his brother, prepares the food herself, and dresses Jacob in Esau’s clothing. Jacob enters the presence of his blind father, and deceiving his senses of taste, touch, and smell, receives the blessing intended for Esau. The scene that follows is among the most devastating in all of Scripture. Esau returns. Isaac trembles. Esau cries out in anguish. “Ha-v’rakhah aḥat hi l’kha avi? Barkheini gam ani, avi! Have you only one blessing, Father? Bless me, too, Father!” Absorbing the enormity of the wrong committed against him, Esau, in a Godfather-worthy scene, vows to kill his brother as soon as their father dies. Hearing Esau’s threat, Rebecca urges Jacob to flee. By the end of the Torah reading, one son is plotting murder, the other is running for his life, and a family has been torn apart.
The tragedy is immense. The fault is everywhere. There is an entire industry of commentary on the question of who is to blame.
The most obvious culprit is Jacob: the one who exploits his brother’s hunger; the one who lies to his father, not once but repeatedly. Indeed, the rabbis of the Midrash suggest that Jacob’s deception comes back to haunt him years later, when Laban tricks him into marrying Leah instead of Rachel. Whatever divine destiny awaits Jacob as the father of our people, he is no innocent bystander. He is an active participant in the family’s unraveling.
No question, Jacob is in the wrong. But before we convict him, what about Esau? Nobody forced him to sell his birthright. He knew what he was doing. He has agency. The Torah itself renders judgment: Va-yivez Esav et ha-b’khorah, Esau spurned his birthright. A man so consumed by impulse and appetite that he sacrifices his future for a bowl of soup. And when things go sideways, Esau’s response is not reflection but a vow of fratricide. Esau, too, must answer for his choices.
But are the children really to blame? What about Rebecca? What kind of mother plays favorites with her children? What sort of mother engineers a deception that pits one son against the other? Sure, God told Rebecca that Jacob is destined for greatness. But does such knowledge justify her behavior? She too has agency. Could she not have found another way? If we are looking for the architect of this disaster, surely Rebecca belongs near the top of the list.
And then there is Isaac. Poor blind old Isaac. The Torah tells us explicitly that Isaac favored Esau. As with so many biblical fathers, there is a whiff of contributory negligence. Our great patriarch was not merely an observer of his family’s dysfunction; his favoritism and his passivity helped fuel it. When Jacob appears before him disguised as Esau, Isaac clearly knows something is amiss. Was Isaac really deceived, or was his blindness willful? Either way, Isaac cannot be absolved of responsibility for the family’s unraveling.
And yes, if we really want to push, what about the God who told Rebecca that the elder would serve the younger in the first place? Why deliver an oracle destined to divide the family? God is God. Why not simply have Jacob be born first? Indeed, the medieval commentator Nachmanides suggests that the entire chain of events – Rebecca’s silence, Isaac’s ignorance, Jacob’s deception – was orchestrated by God to ensure that Jacob received the blessing. It is an observation as uncomfortable as it is inescapable. God set the wheels in motion; does God not bear responsibility for the wreckage that followed?
Jacob. Esau. Rebecca. Isaac. God. There is no shortage of characters to blame. And those are just the ones in this week’s Torah reading. If we really wanted to dig deep into the family’s dysfunction, we could reach back a generation, to Abraham and Sarah. How much of Isaac’s behavior can be traced to his own father’s readiness to bind him upon an altar, prioritizing a divine command over his responsibilities as a parent? Or Sarah? It is hard to read Rebecca’s favoritism without hearing echoes of Sarah’s choice to secure Isaac’s future at Ishmael’s expense. As the rabbinic saying goes, ma’aseh avot siman la-banim, the deeds of the parents are signposts for their children. How much of the present family’s dysfunction is the inheritance of generations past? How much of what appears to be one individual’s failings is actually a family pattern repeating itself?
Whose fault is it? We suffer no shortage of possibilities when it comes to assigning blame to the family feuds of our biblical first family. The depth of the estrangement, the bitterness of the betrayal, the pain of the broken bonds – all invite us to sift through the evidence, to name who is responsible for the disaster. And the more we dig, the more people we find to blame.
And yet, as I read the parashah and combed through the commentaries, I found myself struck by a related but altogether different question: Not whose fault it is, but who cares whose fault it is? Maybe, just maybe, I began to think, the real tragedy of this family is not any single misdeed, misspoken word, misguided intention, or act of deception. Maybe the real tragedy is that everyone is so invested in their own version of what happened, so entrenched in their narrative of grievance, that they lose sight of the family they could still be and the future they could still build together. They are so consumed by the injuries of yesterday that they sacrifice the relationships of tomorrow. And perhaps we, the readers of the text, are by extension guilty of the same mistake. Perhaps we become so fixated on assigning blame, on determining who was wrong, that we lose sight of what our grievances are costing us, and we fail to reckon with what we are forfeiting in the present and the future.
Let me be clear. It is not that fault doesn’t matter. Of course it does. Agency is what makes us human. Actions have consequences. Sins of commission and sins of omission. Wrongs committed with ill will and with the best of intentions. Patterns of behavior inherited from generations past and hurts arising from the imperfections of God’s creation. There is no shortage of wrongdoing, no shortage of hurt, no shortage of people to hold accountable. But at a certain point we have to ask: To what end are we holding on? What purpose is served by rehearsing old injuries, relitigating past grievances, and revisiting the question of who did what to whom? At what point does our insistence on assigning blame become the very thing that prevents us from moving forward?
The patriarchs and matriarchs of the Bible may be our heroes, but their stories speak to us precisely because of their humanity. Their flawed family dynamics, their missteps and misjudgments, their frailties and failings are all mirrored in our own lives. I find myself less interested in the wrongs committed by Jacob and Esau than in the greater tragedy of the twenty years that followed: two decades of estrangement, silence, and separation before the brothers would finally meet again. Twenty years of milestones unmarked, memories never made, relationships left unrealized. Twenty years during which both brothers married, became fathers, and built families, each absent from the milestones, celebrations, and sorrows of the other’s life. Nieces and nephews who never knew their uncles. Cousins who may have known of each other but never knew each other. Lives unfolding in parallel, but never together. And what of Isaac and Rebecca? Parents left to reckon with a family fractured, a home divided, and two sons who could not bear to be in each other’s presence. Twenty years during which everybody carried their own version of the story, their own account of injury, their own conviction of who was to blame. Twenty years of resentment, of distance, of time that could never be reclaimed. That is the tragedy of Jacob and Esau. Not merely what happened between them, but everything that never happened because of it.
This past week, our fabulous synagogue social worker, Suzanne Redlich, shared with me some striking data on family rifts, drawn from Cornell University’s Family Estrangement and Reconciliation Project. A startling twenty-seven percent of American adults – more than one in four – report being estranged from at least one family member. And unlike death or divorce, family estrangement is often what psychologists call ambiguous loss: There is no funeral, no clear moment of closure. The person is gone from your life but remains very much present in your thoughts. It is an open wound that never quite heals, flaring up at birthdays, holidays, weddings, and other family milestones and resulting in chronic stress, rumination, anxiety, and consequences for mental and physical health. And the pain rarely stops with the two people involved. It ripples through the entire family, forcing siblings to choose sides, separating grandparents from grandchildren, and cutting off cousins from cousins. A single fractured relationship becomes a fault line running through generations.
Some of the causes are predictable and identifiable: money and inheritance, a problematic in-law, the lingering legacy of divorce. But often the dynamics are more subtle: the long arm of the past, differences in values or lifestyles, or anger over unmet expectations. We carry assumptions about how family members are supposed to show up – for weddings, funerals, Thanksgiving dinners, or in moments of need. And when they fall short, the disappointment can harden into resentment, the resentment into recrimination, and the recrimination into rupture. No birthright has been stolen, but we feel cheated all the same. Sometimes there is a volcano event – a screaming match, a simcha unattended that becomes the last straw. But more often than not, the rupture is the culmination of countless smaller injuries, slights and disappointments – a death by a thousand cuts. And by the time the relationship finally snaps, the question of who started it has become almost impossible to answer and, frankly, beside the point. Each side has its own story, its own ledger of wrongs. Neither can see a way forward. The tragedies of the biblical family are mirrored in our own.
At the risk of getting ahead of myself, two weeks and twenty years from now, when Jacob and Esau finally reconcile, something remarkable happens, something as significant for what does not happen as for what does. The brothers do not relitigate the past. There is no apology offered, no dramatic confession, no insistence that one brother acknowledge the other’s version of events. Instead, the brothers fall into each other’s arms, embrace, and weep. We know that the night before their reunion, Jacob wrestled with a mysterious adversary – perhaps the demons of his own past. I would like to think that somewhere on the other side of the river, Esau was doing the same thing. As dawn approaches, the decisive moment comes when Jacob is told to release his grip. “Shalḥeini ki alah ha-shaḥar. Let me go, for dawn has broken.” Jacob initially refuses. The symbolism is hard to miss. From the moment he emerged from the womb grasping his brother’s heel, holding on is what Jacob does. Only when Jacob releases his grip, does he receive his new name: Israel. He could only become his fullest self when he finally learned to let go.
For these brothers, as for all of us, it would be nice if reconciliations came with full-throated apologies, acknowledgments of wrongdoing, and acknowledgement that our version of the past was the correct one all along. But at a certain point, we have to reckon with the possibility that such things will never happen. Two people of good will can view a single past completely differently. We may never agree on what actually happened, but we can nevertheless agree on the need to move forward. The absence of consensus about yesterday need not foreclose the possibility of a shared tomorrow.
None of this, needless to say, is easy. It takes time. It takes humility. It takes courage to loosen our grip on grievances that have become part of who we are. Sometimes the struggle is so painful that it feels as though something is being wrenched from its socket. And even then, the wounds do not simply disappear. No different than Jacob emerging from his struggle limping, so too for us. We can nevertheless step forward – toward one another, toward the possibility of blessing, toward the possibility of becoming shalem, whole.
Israel Zangwill once wrote that “It takes two men to make one brother.” With Thanksgiving just around the corner, the pitfalls and possibilities of our families stand in plain view. Each one of us can decide whether we will rehearse old grievances or make room for new memories. We cannot change the past, nor can we compel another person to change. We can, however, choose what we hold on to and what we let go. Jacob and Esau lost twenty years they could never recover. May we have the wisdom not to lose another day.